The International Conference Tirana 2022, on justice inspection services, will bring together in Tirana, on 24 and 25 June 2022, the justice inspection services of the European Union countries, members of the European Network of Justice Inspection Services (RESIJ), established in 2017, where the HIJ has the observer status. This conference in Tirana is organized by RESIJ and the High Inspector of Justice, in cooperation with CEPEJ, with the support of the joint program of the European Union and the Council of Europe “The Horizontal Facility II”.
The conference is part of the activities of RESIJ, where representatives of inspection services, members of RESIJ, depending on the form of inspection services, members of RESIJ, depending on their form of organization, functioning or competencies, will present and exchange their experiences, ideas and research, related to the topics that will be addressed at the conference. Heads and representatives of the Inspection Services of Belgium, Bulgaria, France, Greece, Italy, Portugal, Romania, Spain and Albania through their presentations and discussions will focus on the topic “Public interest in the administration of justice and the independence of magistrates” during three work sessions. The conference will be held at the Presidential Palace in Tirana.
Registration of Participants
Presidential PalaceOpening Remarks.
09:00 - 09:05
Mr. Artur Metani, High Inspector of Justice of the Republic of Albania
09:05 - 09:10
Mrs. Lindita Nikolla, Speaker of the Parliament of the Republic of Albania
09:10 - 09:15
Mr. Alexis Hupin, Chargé d'Affaires at the European Union Delegation to Albania
09:15 - 09:20
Mr. Demian Smith, Chargé d'Affaires at the U.S. Embassy in Albania
09:20 - 09:25
Mr. Olsi Dekovi, Deputy Head of Office, Council of Europe Office in Tirana
11:30
Mr. Christophe Straudo, Chairman of the Inspectorate General of France and President of the European Network of Justice Inspection Services (RESIJ) (online)
Mrs. Muriel Decot Secretary of the CEPEJ (European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice) (online)
SESSION I: Competencies, organization and functioning of Justice Inspection Services. A comparative perspective.
Moderator: Mr. Lucian Netejoru, Head of Inspectorate, Judicial Inspectorate, Romania
09:30 - 09:45
The Judicial Inspectorate of Romania, various forms of organization, functioning and relations with other institutions.
Mr. Lucian Netejoru, Head of Inspectorate, Judicial Inspectorate, Romania
09:45 - 10:00
Conducting inspections and disciplinary proceedings of magistrates in order to increase public confidence in the justice system in Greece.
Mr. Nikolaos Pipiligkas, Vice President of the Supreme Court for Civil
and Criminal Cases "Areios Pagos" Greece.
10:00 - 10:15
Competencies, organization and functioning of the Bulgarian inspectorates responsible for the control of magistrates. The practice of the Bulgarian Inspectorate regarding the declaration and control of the property interests of magistrates as a guarantee of their independence and integrity in order to increase public confidence in the judicial system.
Mrs. Maria Neykova, Inspector, Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria
Mr. Lyubomir Krumov, Inspector, Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria
10:15 - 10:30
Inspection and control of work of magistrates and courts according to the Italian legislation. Role and activity of the inspection services.
Mrs. Maria Rosaria Covelli, Head of General Inspectorate,
General Inspectorate of the Ministry of Justice, Italy
10:30 - 11:00
Discussions.
All participants
11:00 - 11:30
Coffee Break / Family Photo
SESSION II: Independence and accountability of magistrates. Guarantees and disciplinary proceedings of magistrates.
Moderator: Mr. Vincent Delbos, General Inspector of Justice(honorary), member of the Committee for the Prevention of Torture, Council of Europe
11:30 - 11:45
The right of expression of magistrates and its restriction according to the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). Disciplinary liability in these cases.
Mr. Darian Pavli, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights (Online)
11:45 -12:00
Disciplinary responsibility of magistrates in relation to their independence.
Mr. Vitor Manuel Ribeiro, Judicial Inspector, High Council of Magistracy, Portugal
12:00 - 12:15
Investigation and disciplinary proceedings of magistrates in accordance with the guarantees of a due process of law provided for in Article 6/1 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).
Mrs. Béatrice Del Volgo, General Inspector, General Inspectorate of Justice, France
12:15 - 12:30
Disciplinary responsibility and the limits of control of work of magistrates.
Mrs. Emanuela Aliverti, Inspector, General Inspectorate of the Ministry of Justice, Italy
12:30 - 12:45
Justice inspection service, between the independence and accountability of magistrates.
Mr. Michail Pikramenos, Vice President, Council of State , Greece
12:45 - 13:00
Discussions.
All participants
13:00 - 14:30
Lunch
Session III: The role of inspection services as a guarantor for the proper functioning and independence of the justice system, in accordance with international and European standards. Methods and challenges of the future.
Moderator: Mrs. Delphine Agoguet, Inspector, General Inspectorate of Justice, France
14:30 - 14:45
Development of control and inspection procedures of the justice system through the application of new technologies.
Mrs. Amparo Camazon Linacero, Head of the Inspection Service, High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online)
Mrs. Elena Burgos Herrera, Inspector, High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online)
14:45 - 15:00
The role of inspection services, as a guarantor of the proper functioning and independence of the justice system in accordance with European legislation and best practices.
Mrs. Valérie Delfosse, Magistrate(judge), President of the French Speaking Commission of Inquiry of the Superior Council of Justice, Belgium
15:00 - 15:15
Transition from inspection bodies based on the evaluation of judges and prosecutors (inspections to magistrates) to services responsible for evaluating the quality and performance of courts (court-based inspections). Some lessons from projects in Council of Europe member states and beyond. Possible methods and challenges for the inspection services.
Mr. Vincent Delbos, General Inspector of Justice(honorary), member of the Committee for the Prevention of Torture, Council of Europe
15:15 - 15:45
Discussions.
All participants
15:45 - 16:00
Conclusions of the Conference
Mr. Artur Metani, High Inspector of Justice, Albania
Mrs. BÉATRICE DEL VOLGO
General Inspector
General Inspectorate of Justice
France
Mrs. Béatrice Del Volgo entered the justice system with a competitive exam after graduating with a master's degree in private law.
Initially, she worked as a Judge of Inquiry in the investigative hearings in Corsica and Marseilles, where she specialized in organized crime, and later on in the Financial and Economic Affairs.
She continued working in the same field as an adviser to the court of Appeal Aix en Provence in the Correctional Chamber specializing in Financial and Economic matters.
For several years she has been practicing her profession in a public prosecutor's office, where she has mainly dealt with juvenile cases.
She has worked as an Inspector in the General Inspectorate of Judicial Services, and later as a General Inspector in the General Inspectorate of Justice. Currently, she is the Head of the Department of Ethics and Administrative Inspections.
Mr. VITOR MANUEL RIBEIRO
Judicial Inspector
High Council of Magistracy
Portugal
Mrs. EMANUELA ALIVERTI
Inspector
General Inspectorate of Ministry of Justice
Italy
Mrs. Emanuela Aliverti graduated in Foreign Languages (English-French) in 1978 and in 1983 graduated in Justice at the University “Cattolica del Sacro Cuore” in Milan. In 1986 she was appointed justice auditor.
During her career, Mrs. Aliverti served as a civil judge as well as for minors. She was labor judge, for custody, uncontested procedures, sentencing judge, and titular judge of the First Instance Court.
Since 1992 she has been a judge of the Como Court in the First Civil Chamber (matters related to real rights, persons and family relations, company law, liabilities, inheritance, and labor disputes) and in the Second Civil Chamber (matters related to property rights, intellectual and industrial rights, contractual and non-contractual liability, inheritance, entrepreneurship, paternity denial procedures, adoption of the adults, and correction of gender determination, termination of pregnancy in minor women, shortened proceedings and complaints). Furthermore, from 2004 to 2010, employee and then judge at the Juvenile Court of Bologna, of Milan, and then until 2014 counselor of the First Civil Chamber at the Court of Appeal of Milan.
Mrs. Aliverti has worked as General Inspector in the General Inspectorate in the Ministry of Justice from 2014 to January 2022. From March 2022 she is the Coordinator of the International Group of the General Inspectorate in the Ministry of Justice.
During her career, Mrs. Emanuela Aliverti has been part of the Examinations Board of the candidates for the title of lawyer, and magistrates; was a mentor-judge in Vocational training school for magistrates, referrer in the training courses for peace judges, lawyers, the judicial auditor in the Italian General Inspectorate and has referred in a lot of seminars and international conferences for justice like in Rabat, Marakesh, Tirana, Paris, Casablanca and in the framework of RESIJ.
Mrs. VALÉRIE DELFOSSE
Magistrate (Judge)
President of the French Speaking Commission of Inquiry of the Superior Council of Justice,
Belgium
Mr. LUCIAN NETEJORU
Head of Inspectorate
Judicial Inspectorate
Romania
Mr. MICHAIL PIKRAMENOS
Vice President
Council of State
Greece
Mrs. MARIA NEYKOVA,
Inspector
Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council
Bulgaria
Mr. LYUBOMIR KRUMOV
Inspector
Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council
Bulgaria
Mr. DARIAN PAVLI
Judge at the European Court of Human Rights (Online)
Mrs. AMPARO CAMAZON LINACERO,
Head of the Inspection Service
High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online)
Part of the judicial system since 1980.
Mrs. ELENA BURGOS HERRERA
Inspector
High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online)
Part of the judicial system since 2000.
Superior Council of Justice, Belgium
Mrs. Valérie Delfosse, Magistrate (judge), President of the French Speaking Commission of Inquiry of the Superior Council of Justice, Belgium
General Inspectorate of Justice, France
Mrs. Béatrice del Volgo, General Inspector, General Inspectorate of Justice, France. Mrs. Delphine Agoguet Inspector, General Inspectorate of Justice, France
Supreme Court for Civil and Criminal Cases “Areios Pagos” Greece
Mr. Nikolaos Pipiligkas Vice President of the Supreme Court for Civil and Criminal Cases «Areios Pagos», Greece
High Council of Magistracy, Portugal
Mr. Vitor Manuel Ribeiro, Judicial Inspector High Council of Magistracy, Portugal
High Council of Judiciary, Spain
Mrs. Amparo Camazon Linacero, Head of the Inspection Service, High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online). Mrs. Elena Burgos Herrera, Inspector, High Council of Judiciary, Spain (Online)
European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice (CEPEJ)
Mrs. Muriel Decot Secretary of the CEPEJ (European Commission for the Efficiency of Justice) (online)
European Court of Human Rights
Mr. Darian Pavli, Judge at the European Court of Human Rights (Online)
Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria
Mrs. Maria Neykova, Inspector, Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria. Mr. Lyubomir Krumov, Inspector, Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria. Mrs. Nina Nikolova, Expert, Inspectorate to the Supreme Judicial Council, Bulgaria.
Council of State, Greece
Mr. Michail Pikramenos Vice President,Council of State, Greece
Judicial Inspectorate, Romania
Mr. Lucian Netejoru, Head of Inspectorate, Judicial Inspectorate, Romania. Mrs.Roxana Petcu, Inspector, Judicial Inspectorate, Romania
General Inspectorate of the Ministry of Justice, Italy
Mrs. Maria Rosaria Covelli Head of General Inspectorate, General Inspectorate of the Ministry of Justice, Italy. Mrs. Emanuela Aliverti, Inspector, General Inspectorate of the Ministry of Justice, Italy
High Inspector of Justice, Albania
Mr. Artur Metani, High Inspector of Justice, Albania
Council of Europe
Mr. Vincent Delbos, General Inspector of Justice(honorary), member of the Committee for the Prevention of Torture, Council of Europe
RÉSEAU EUROPÉEN
DES SERVICES D'INSPECTION
DE LA JUSTICE
In 2017, representatives of the inspection services of 14 member states of the European Union but not only, in order to develop methods and tools of cooperation have agreed on the establishment of the European Network of Justice Inspection Services (RESIJ). This network mainly aims at identifying issues and conducting joint training at European level; increasing the role of national inspection services in assessing the effectiveness and quality of justice at European level; as well as evaluation of European instruments of mutual judicial assistance in civil and criminal matters; developing opportunities for funding by the European Union or the Council of Europe of a number of initiatives related to the work processes of the inspection services of RESIJ member countries; drafting standard documents related to the exercise of inspection activity or those of inspectors' ethics. In the meeting of 10th December 2021 of RESIJ, it was decided that the institution of the High Inspector of Justice, of the Republic of Albania to be part of this European network with the status of observer.
The High Inspector of Justice of Albania (HIJ) was established on 1 February 2020 as a new constitutional independent institution responsible for reviewing complaints, investigating disciplinary violations and initiating disciplinary proceedings against judges and prosecutors of all levels, members of the High Judicial Council, members of the High Prosecutorial Council and the Prosecutor General. The High Inspector of Justice is elected by the Parliament. HIJ is a new institution, therefore, creating a culture of independence, professionalism and effectiveness is both a legal obligation and a challenge. In this regard, setting standards on reviewing complaints, handling them expediently and ex officio investigating disciplinary violations is of particular and long term importance
Funded by the European Union and the Council of Europe
Implemented by the Council of Europe
The aim of the CEPEJ is the improvement of the efficiency and functioning of justice in the member States, and the development of the implementation of the instruments adopted by the Council of Europe to this end. CEPEJ is working with the High Inspector of Justice of Albania in the frame of the second phase of the “Horizontal Facility for the Western Balkans and Turkey - Phase II” programme, SEJ III Action “Strengthening the Efficiency and Quality of the justice system in Albania”, co-financed by the European Union and the Council of Europe and implemented by the Council of Europe.
Tirana International Conference of Justice Inspection Services 2022
For any queries, please send an e-mail to
hijconference@ild.al